#39 - Thiel Fellowship, Backing Young People | Danielle Strachman, 1517 Fund

Relentless • • 1h13 → 4 min • #39
#39 - Thiel Fellowship, Backing Young People | Danielle Strachman, 1517 Fund
Watch on YouTube

Summary

  • Danielle Strachman, co-founder and general partner at 1517 Fund, describes how the firm backs very young builders through small “belief capital” grants, larger venture checks, and a long-term community that treats founders as captains of their own ships while 1517 acts as navigator.

The Medici Project: small grants as belief capital

  • The Medici Project began as unnamed “nudge grants” of $1,000 given to teens at Thiel Foundation summits who simply wanted to talk about an idea, not pitch a company.
  • The insight: young people usually get money only as a prize for something already built; giving resources before a finished product unlocks hidden talent that lacks early access to capital.
  • Max Lockach received $1,000 for a freight-forwarding idea while still in high school; he later nearly won TechCrunch Disrupt and raised outside funding.
  • Noah Shuddy (DeepGram, now Series C) was met in a Michigan frat house during a hackathon weekend; he described an algorithm idea in a room with leftover party pants and a belt, and 1517 granted him $1,000 on the spot.
  • Ethan (Mach Industries) got a high-school grant to work on a novel rifle; that project evolved into Mach Industries, where 1517 wrote the first check.
  • A 16-year-old making hyper-realistic stuffed-animal heads received a grant after a call where she admitted, “I don’t know how to do this”; Strachman recognized her engineering mindset applied to craft and is now connecting her to bioprinting experts.
  • The grant is deliberately for projects, not companies; some become companies, many stay projects, and both outcomes are celebrated.
  • Strachman emphasizes the psychological power of an early “yes”: after a string of rejections, a single believer can shift a young person from “am I crazy?” to “someone else thinks I’m right.”

Finding high-potential young people earlier

  • 1517’s network operates like tendrils: grantees, founders, and community members spot outliers and refer them (e.g., an 11-year-old ship-design enthusiast in Toronto was introduced by a grantee; 1517 arranged a field trip with a portfolio ship-design company).
  • Strachman, a former educator who founded a Montessori-inspired charter school, personally mentors younger children and runs a camp (2E) for ages 14–18.
  • She advocates Montessori/unschooling principles: treat children with reverence, preserve their innate agency, prepare environments where resources are at their level, and avoid one-size-fits-all systems.
  • Her godchildren illustrate the point: each thrives in a different structure (traditional, nature-based, future homeschooling), reinforcing that optimal childhoods are highly individual.

The role of an early believer

  • A great early believer helps the founder map their own path, connects them to relevant people, and uses Socratic dialogue rather than directive advice (“I’m older, do it my way”).
  • Strachman explicitly labels which “hat” she’s wearing (investor, educator, personal) so founders can weigh input accordingly.
  • The mantra: “You’re the captain of your ship; we’re the navigator looking ahead.”
  • Sometimes the navigator sees rocks the captain doesn’t: Strachman recalled aggressively warning a founder against a premature crowdfunding campaign because a previous founder ignored the same warning, smashed into the rocks, and is still delivering years late.
  • Founder-to-founder troubleshooting calls (Friday “coffee and troubleshooting”) let peers warn each other in a more trusted voice than investors.

How 1517 works with founders

  • Engagement starts with an onboarding call that delivers two messages: (1) “We believe you could be a fund-returner” (1517 targets 4× per fund; Fund I returned 4.5×), and (2) “The most likely outcome of any single investment is zero, so swing for the fences—we’d rather you flame out early and move on than peter out.”
  • Ongoing interaction is proactive Socratic review: “What do the next three months look like? Where are the rocks? What conversations are you delaying?”
  • Expertise leans toward leadership development; technical questions are referred to specialist founders in the network.
  • Capital deployment follows a scaffolded ladder: $1,000 Medici grant → $100K R&D check (e.g., Human at Soulcoa, rare-earth extraction, started at 15 in parents’ basement) → pre-seed/seed millions → follow-on reserves and SPVs for highest-conviction companies (Luminar, Lambda Labs).
  • “ATM machine, password is traction”: when a portfolio company shows real progress, 1517 moves fast and rings the dinner bell for LPs via SPVs.

The question Strachman asks most

  • “Would I have wanted to meet this person in the Thiel Fellowship finalist round?” — looking for irrational, passionate, geeky, mutant-level conviction.
  • A secondary sorting-hat question: community member → grantee → investee → at what level? 1517 watches progress over years and avoids boxing people as “too early” forever, unlike many later-stage investors who anchor on first impressions.

If she had $10B: build an ecosystem of fellowships

  • Vision: a massive family office / fund-of-funds backing every niche fellowship program (cash, mentorship, community, arts, science) that operates with genuine care and calling, not as a stepping stone.
  • Small, high-touch programs (like Paul Graham cooking dinner for early YC batches) retain magic that doesn’t scale; better to fund many such programs than to centralize.
  • She wants to run experiments: e.g., drive the Bay Area giving $1,000 to non-degreed painters, host a summer showcase, bring tech buyers, and measure medium-term impact on artists’ trajectories.

Prolific creators and the artist/entrepreneur distinction

  • Prolific output compounds: Picasso made art daily from teens to death; most was forgotten, the few masterpieces defined him.
  • 1517 founders often have a parallel creative practice (painting, music, side art sales) — the medium changes but the generative, playful, curious streak is constant.
  • Artists create because they must, largely for themselves; entrepreneurs create because they must but must care what others think to find customers. The most interesting people straddle both.

Finding your tribe

  • For 15 years young builders have said, “I don’t get to meet other people like me.” Fellowships and communities are finally reducing that isolation.
  • Peer environments where ideas are jammed on without credential-checking (“What college? What major?”) are a critical accelerant.

Hardest thing overcome: founding Innovations Academy in the 2008 crash

  • At 28, Strachman co-founded a Montessori-inspired charter school (Innovations Academy) in San Diego. A “guaranteed” $250K Walton Foundation grant was denied because the model was non-hierarchical (co-principals), first-name basis, no homework, social-emotional curriculum — all “strange” to the funder.
  • Lease signed, 130 students enrolled, zero state funding until butts-in-seats. A friend’s mother and a colleague’s brother each lent $75K; the recession hit; it took four years to repay.
  • Strachman couldn’t look the lender in the eye for years. The experience informs 1517’s ethos: “We make money on extraordinary returns, not by clawing back small amounts from struggling founders.” She recently heard of a founder who took contracting gigs to repay a $250K investor check out of fear — exactly the dynamic 1517 refuses to create.
Back to Relentless